BudPing Join the waitlist

Exchange rates

You paid for it in March. It should not cost more in September.

Open some multi currency expense trackers in September and the dinner you had in March has quietly gone up. Nothing happened to the dinner. The exchange rate moved, and the app converted every old transaction again with today's rate. Your budget for March changed six months after March ended. BudPing is an expense tracker that keeps the exchange rate with each entry instead. Here is what that means for the numbers you see.

Join the waitlist

The problem with converting again

If every past entry is converted with the current rate, three things go wrong. Your spending history drifts, so a month that was under budget can show as over budget later. Your records stop matching what you actually paid. You paid a specific amount on a specific day, and that is what should stay in your history. And you cannot tell what actually changed, because a number can move without anything having happened.

For someone with everything in one currency none of this matters. For someone with a salary in riyals, rent in pesos, a card in euros and parents in rupees, it means the app can only ever be roughly right.

What keeping the rate means

When you record an entry in a currency other than the one you chose for your total, BudPing saves two things: the amount in its own currency, and the rate that applied that day between that currency and your total's currency. Both are stored with the entry and are not worked out again later. Only you can change them, by editing that entry. The dinner stays at the rate of the day you paid for it, which is what people mean by a locked or historical exchange rate.

The same applies to transfers between accounts in different currencies. They are recorded as two linked entries, the amount that left and the amount that arrived, and the rate between them is fixed at that moment, from the rate you entered or the day's rate.

What moves and what does not

FigureWhen the rate changes
An entry in its own currencyStays as recorded.
The same entry in your total's currencyKept at the rate of that day.
An account's balance in its own currencyStays as recorded. Rates do not touch it.
A budget and its spent figureDoes not move. It is the sum of the entries, each at its own rate.
A transfer between currenciesStays at the rate you got.
Your total across all accountsMoves with the live rate. This is the one figure that should.

That last line is on purpose. What you hold today is worth today's rate. What you spent in March was paid at March's rate. Many apps mix the two.

Try it: move today's rate

EUR to QAR today4.05
Dinner in March, EUR 60.00recorded at 4.05 that daykept
Euro account, EUR 46,757.00what it is worth in your total right nowlive

The dinner does not move. The balance does, because what you hold today is worth what today says. Example figures.

When there is no rate

Rates are fetched when the phone is online and the last known ones are kept for when it is not. If no rate is available for a pair, BudPing does not treat the two currencies as equal and move on. It asks you for the rate, or leaves the conversion open until one is available. A guessed rate would give you a number that looks right and is not.

Why your budget needs this

Budgets in BudPing are not running totals that get nudged each time you add something. Every time anything changes, the spent figure is added up again from the entries. Because each entry carries its own fixed rate, that sum is the same today as it will be in a year. A budget that showed 64% spent in March still shows 64% when you look back at March.

It also means an entry can be corrected without side effects. Fix a typo in one amount and only that entry's figures change. The rest is left alone.

The rate, kept

Saved with the entry on the day you paid.

Budgets that cannot drift

Spend is summed again on every change.

One live total

The only figure that follows today's rate.

Common questions

Does BudPing change my old transactions when the exchange rate changes?
No. Each transaction keeps the amount and the rate it was recorded with. The only figure that follows today's rate is the live total across your accounts.

Does it recalculate old expenses?
No. Nothing is worked out again with a newer rate. If you change an entry yourself, only that entry changes.

Is this what people mean by a locked or historical exchange rate?
Yes. The rate that applied on the day is saved with the transaction and used for it from then on.

Where do the rates come from?
They are fetched over the internet when the phone is online and kept for use when it is not. For a transfer between your own accounts, you enter the amount sent and the rate you got, or use the day's rate.

Can I see the rate an entry was recorded at?
The rate is kept with the entry, alongside the amount in its own currency.

What if I entered the wrong amount?
Change it. Only that entry is affected. The rest of your history keeps the rates it was recorded with.

Where are the records kept?
In an encrypted database on your phone. The privacy policy sets out what does and does not reach us.

BudPing is not open yet. If this is the problem you have, put your email on the waitlist and we will write once, when it opens.

Join the waitlist